10 Things to Look for in a Content Marketing Agency Before Hiring

So, you’ve taken the leap – and finally decided to up your game and hire a content marketing agency to help amplify your brand’s message!

Whether you need an extra hand with content creation, more help managing your brand’s online presence, or someone who can lead strategic content campaigns, hiring a content marketing agency can be one of the best decisions you make for your growing business.

But there’s a catch…

How can you be sure you’re hiring the right team for the job? Are there any tell-tale signs that can help lead you in the right direction? What if you choose someone who doesn’t vibe with you or what you’re doing?!

Slow down, take a deep breath… it’s all gonna be OK. 

Before you go diving headfirst into the content pool, you’ll be glad to hear there are a few ways to make sure you’re partnering with the right content marketing agency. Let’s dive in.

What can a content marketing agency do for you?

Ever heard the saying “Content rules all”? Well, it turns out it’s not just a catchy phrase… it’s the reality of today’s fast-paced, ever-evolving digital marketing landscape.

But let’s be honest for a second: creating killer content isn’t as easy as slapping a few words together and calling it a day. 

That’s where a content marketing agency comes into play. 

From helping you craft compelling long-form content to brand design, strategy, and more, let’s unravel the magic behind the agency to see what you’ll be paying for.

1. Craft compelling content

From snazzy blog posts to in-depth whitepapers, a content marketing agency can weave words into gold. Through industry insights and experience, they know exactly how to deliver the right message to the right audience at the right time.

2. Strategy development

Content without strategy is like a ship without a compass. An agency can help you chart your content course, ensuring that every piece serves a purpose and brings you closer to your goals.

Looking for a content marketing partner who can help you create content and develop a strategy that’ll bring you closer to your audience? Our Strategy Intensives are designed to help you get to the core of what makes your brand stand out.

3. Level up your SEO

Want to rank on Google? An agency has the SEO knowledge you need to help you show up on search engines without having to pay for a spot at the top.

4. Leverage video, design, and more

Content isn’t just about the written word. Whether it’s engaging videos, infographics, or podcasts, an agency has the know-how to diversify your content offerings.

5. Data analysis + reporting

Agencies love their numbers. That’s why they’ll dig deep into analytics to find out what’s working, what’s not, and where you can optimize for better results.

6. Keep your branding consistent

Consistency is key in branding, right? Well, a content marketing agency can be there to make sure that your brand voice rings true across all platforms, creating a cohesive image that your audience recognizes and trusts.

7. Upgrade your social media presence

From Threads to TikTok, agencies know how to tailor content for various social platforms and ensure maximum reach and engagement.

In addition to these tasks, a good content marketing agency can do more than just do things for you. 

For one, they can be there to support you as you learn to navigate the complicated marketing landscape. From teaching you about SEO best practices to leveraging data analytics, working with a content marketing agency can make the difference between following what you hear on a podcast and actually knowing your sh*t when it comes to marketing.

Plus, they can also serve as a sounding board for all your creative ideas. Having a group of experts to bounce off ideas means you get feedback from those who’ve been in the game for longer than you have. This connection, in turn, ensures that your strategies aren’t just innovative but also effective. 

So whether you’re considering a new content format or exploring a fresh marketing channel, their advice can save you from making any costly missteps.

10 things to look out for when hiring a content marketing agency

Choosing the right content marketing agency is all about knowing how to spot the red flags before you agree to partner with them. 

Sure, with the right partnership, your business could soar… but choose the wrong team, and it might push you all the way back to square one.

However, we’ve been in the game for long enough to know how this goes. 

Let’s take a closer look at the 10 most important things you need to look out for when you’re first meeting with an agency:

1. They have a track record of success

A solid content marketing agency isn’t just about fluff and pizazz – it’s about results. Always ask for case studies, testimonials, or references. 

Remember, actions speak louder than words (or flashy Canva pitch deck)!

Look through The Quirky Pineapple Studio’s portfolio for an example of our past work in brand message strategy, copywriting, and content marketing.

2. They’re transparent and clear

Every successful relationship is built on trust. That said, your chosen agency should be an open book when it comes to its methodologies, pricing structures, and potential challenges. 

If they’re cagey about details or dodge straightforward questions, it’s a red flag. No one likes unpleasant surprises – especially when your brand’s reputation and resources are on the line.

3. They create tailored strategies, not a one-size-fits-all approach

Your business has its own identity, goals, and audience. A good content marketing agency recognizes this and doesn’t just regurgitate the same strategy across all its clients. 

Instead, they should take the time to understand your brand, audience, and objectives in order to craft a bespoke plan that’s tailor-made for success.

At The Quirky Pineapple Studio, we’ve developed a framework for our brand message and content marketing strategies – one that is sustainable, holistic, and keeps your brand story at the forefront to build community and loyal clients. This framework then gets applied to your business and brand’s culture, identity, goals, and audience. We always work to adapt our framework to best fit your needs as a brand and business. 

4. They have a great team behind them

An agency is only as good as its team. Make sure that the people working on your brand have all of the necessary experience and, well… likeability to take on the role. 

After all, this is a partnership, and personal dynamics can play a significant role in the collaboration’s success.

5. They make data-driven decisions

Gut feelings have their place, but in the world of content marketing, data doesn’t lie. With this in mind, a good content marketing agency uses analytics, insights, and thorough research to guide strategies, measure outcomes, and continuously refine the approach. 

This commitment to data ensures that your strategy remains up-to-date and effective.

6. They “practice what they preach”

Taking a peek at an agency’s own content marketing efforts can be quite revealing. If they advocate for a certain tactic or platform, check them out to see if they’re leveraging it effectively as part of their own strategy – or if they can explain the reason they’re not doing it. 

7. They believe in flexibility & adaptability

The digital world is ever-evolving. Algorithms change, new platforms emerge, and audience behaviors shift. Because of this, your chosen agency should not only be aware of these changes but also quick and flexible enough to adjust strategies accordingly.

Being quick and adaptable is a great way to ensure that your brand can stay at the forefront.

8. They’re all about clear communication

FACT: misunderstandings can lead to wasted resources and missed opportunities. In order to avoid this, it’s important that you and your chosen content marketing agency prioritize open, clear, and regular communication. 

This includes providing updates, seeking feedback, and keeping everyone in the loop.

For example, when we work with clients on content creation and management, we build out a content production workflow and operationalize it. Our goal is to keep clear communication channels, always, and develop a system around your content marketing efforts so work is streamlined and efficient.

9. They have a passion for your brand + message

A content marketing agency is there to act as a partner. That said, it’s important that they genuinely connect with your brand’s values, mission, and story. 

This deep-rooted understanding will then translate into content that’s not only skillfully crafted but also brimming with authentic enthusiasm.

At The Quirky Pineapple Studio, we’re passionate about working with business owners and thought leaders who are changing the game and unleashing positive impact in their community. Check out the different ways we can work together to help you stand out!

10. They’re competitively priced

As a small business owner, value for money is key. However, while it’s tempting to opt for the cheapest option, it’s crucial to weigh the cost against the quality of the services offered. Similarly, a high price tag doesn’t automatically guarantee top-tier results. 

Research, compare, and find an agency that strikes the right balance between cost and value and that fits into your budget without spreading you too thin.

TL;DR: Do your research… and trust your gut

Choosing the right content marketing agency is like matchmaking – bear with us on this one! 

After all, you’re not just looking for anyone – you’re looking for the one. “The one” who understands your vision, shares your passion and can drive tangible results. And more than just ticking boxes or going by reputation alone, it’s a relationship built on the idea of synergy, alignment, and a shared mindset.

This means that as soon as things start going wrong… it’s time to swipe left!

The bottom line, however, is that this checklist can serve as a starting point as to what to look out for and what to look into… it’s also important that you lean into your instincts. 

Ready to take your content marketing to the next level? Our Content Creation & Management service is the perfect way to get back in touch with your brand and create bangin’ content… without having to do all of the things. From social media to blog and email marketing, let The Quirky Pineapple Studio take care of it all.

Sure, meetings, calls, and proposals might give you the facts, but your intuition will often whisper truths about the potential for a real partnership that isn’t as clear to see from what a content marketing agency is painting. 

So go ahead and trust both your research and your gut feeling – and happy hiring!

Looking for brand strategy or copy support?

Schedule a call to learn how we can help you with brand messaging, copywriting, or content marketing!

Posted in
brand strategist with pineapple, copywriter holding pineapple, the quirky pineapple studio


We’re a brand strategy & copywriting studio for mission-driven, BIPOC, LGBTQIA+, and Feminist-run brands and businesses who want to increase their visibility and connect with their communities through the power of story and content. We share tips & advice on how to make marketing (and business) fun!

content marketing and strategy resource for small businesses

Want to get a content marketing strategy that doesn’t involve burn out? Download our Content Generating Machine ebook to help you cut your content marketing time down, repurpose like a pro, and never run out of ideas!

Heartfel Copywriting Bundle

The Heartfelt Copywriting Bundle

A comprehensive resource to help you write personality-filled website copy and share your message through powerful words that convert your readers to clients. Learn how to write your own website copy with this bundle!